Game of the Year Game of the Year 2020 Podcasts

The Free Cheese Game of the Year 2020

January 22, 2021


The Free Cheese Game of the Year 2020

This year, we’re changing a bit of how our awards are chosen and announced. We’re limiting the entire process to a single, shorter episode. We’ve worked behind the scenes using a spreadsheet and some math, with a bit of wiggling one way or another to determine the winners of each category.

As we read through each category, we’ll name the winner and two runners up. Then, we’ll share some of our experiences with each game and why it deserved the award.

We’re going to spend a few minutes throughout the episode to celebrate some of the games that stuck with us the most in 2020. These might not have been released in 2020, but they meant something to us when we played them. In between rounds of award winners, we’ll each share a game that meant something to us and why.

When we reach Game of the Year, we will read our current list of nominees and deliberate the winner as we would in previous years, eventually crowning a winner.

Out of Time

While we found ourselves with more time to play games this year, we still have games that we missed out on playing. For one reason or another the games we nominate slipped through the cracks. The award goes to the game that we wish we would have played and will hopefully be talking about throughout the next year.

Winner: Spelunky 2

Runners Up: Nioh 2, Paper Mario: The Origami King

Favorite Industry Moment

One thing that has continually brought us together are those times in the video game industry where developers and publishers get to show off what they have been creating.

While 2020 was a change in the way we typically received video game news, we saw companies find new ways to reach us and we were able to share excitement and hope for something new.

Winner: Tony Hawk’s Pro Skater 1 + 2 Reveal

Runners Up: Open World Navigation Map Reveal for Halo Infinite, Demon’s Souls Remake Announcement

2020’s 2019 Game of the Year

As we are highlighting even more this year than previous years, we play a lot more than just what was released in a single year and often find ourselves catching up with something from the year before.

While last year, we never landed on a winner, we found ourselves with quite a bit of 2019’s games to choose from this year.

Winner: Ring Fit Adventure

Runners Up: Tetris 99, Untitled Goose Game

Retrospective #1

2020 was the perfect year to get lost in something. We each felt the pull of exploration and a want for discovery, and we each found our own answers to satisfy the need.

  • Metroid: Other M
  • Dark Souls
  • Half-Life/Black Mesa

Best Xbox Game

Microsoft managed to transition into a new generation of consoles with ease and Xbox Game Pass let us stay up with everything published by the first-party. This year continued to exemplify why Xbox Game Pass is essential for Xbox owners.

Winner: Ori and the Will of the Wisps

Runners Up: Phantasy Star Online 2, Tetris Effect Connected

Best Multiplayer

Since we played our first game we have found a way to share it with others, even when it wasn’t designed to do so. This award is for the game that did something special to unite us, for the game that found a way to get us playing together.

Winner: Trackmania

Runners Up: Phasmophobia, Deep Rock Galactic

Best DLC/Expansion

Downloadable content, expansions, and updates are a regular part of video games today. Thanks to post-game support, the games we love the most can get even better. Some games turn around entirely and become something we never thought they would. This award is for the piece of content that made the biggest impact on us in 2020.

Winner: Super Smash Bros. Ultimate x Sephiroth

Runners Up: Super Smash Bros. Ultimate x Minecraft, Pokémon Sword and Shield: The Isle of Armor

Retrospective #2

In a console release year, it’s strange that we didn’t have a racing game to test drive new consoles with. Two were announced, but without release dates. Instead, we explored some of racing’s past to see how the genre can change, and we looked at racing with a new perspective.

  • Daytona USA
  • Motorsport Manager
  • F-Zero X

Best PlayStation Game

With the end of one of its most successful generations, PlayStation was home to so many exclusives that took advantage of the years spent on with the hardware. Games on PlayStation 4 in 2020 were often long in development and finally came to us just as we looked beyond to the next generation.

Winner: Final Fantasy VII Remake

Runners Up: 13 Sentinels: Aegis Rim, Persona 5 Royal

Best Ongoing Game

More than a single update or piece of content, video games have the chance to live. We all have the one game that we keep coming back to, and this award celebrates the games that remain fresh and continue to offer reasons for us to return.

Winner: Call of Duty

Runners Up: Animal Crossing: New Horizons, Rocket League

Most Surprising

This award is for the game that we had no idea we wanted. In some cases, our nominees were first announced and released in the same year where others simply caught us off guard with what they ended up doing upon release.

Winner: Tony Hawk’s Pro Skater 1 + 2

Runners Up: Hyrule Warriors: Age of Calamity, 13 Sentinels: Aegis Rim

Retrospective #3

2020 was a year where we were able to say “What was that game?” We spent time with relics of the past otherwise forgotten to history, got lost in a world through another lens, and finally stepped into the games that got away.

  • The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt
  • AeroPorter
  • Umurangi Generations

Best Nintendo Game

Nintendo was different this year than I think any of us had anticipated. Listening back through our predictions, you can hear what we expected from Nintendo in 2020 and seeing a smaller year for Nintendo was a bit of a surprise. Even with some absences from the release calendar, Nintendo celebrated the 35th anniversary of Super Mario Bros., released a thirty year old Fire Emblem in the West for the first time, and even snuck out a new Game & Watch model.

Winner: Animal Crossing: New Horizons

Runners Up: Hyrule Warriors: Age of Calamity, Xenoblade Chronicles: Definitive Edition

Most Anticipated

Suffice it to say, 2020’s release calendar is a lot different than we or the developers making the games anticipated it would be. A lot of what we were excited to play slipped into 2021, to the point where new consoles launched without the one. Rather than grant an award to a single game, we’re instead going to share three games each that we’re most looking forward to in 2021.

Game of the Year

  1. Final Fantasy VII Remake
  2. Persona 5 Royal
  3. Tony Hawk’s Pro Skater 1+2
  4. 13 Sentinels: Aegis Rim
  5. Yakuza: Like a Dragon
  6. Animal Crossing: New Horizons
  7. Superliminal
  8. Ori and the Will of the Wisps
  9. Demon’s Souls
  10. The Last of Us Part 2

Joe is the creator of The Free Cheese. He eats a lot of pizza and takes thousands of pictures of his pugs Oswald and Earl every day.
One Comment
  1. Marie (Rio)

    Excellent reviews!

Leave a comment

Say Something!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.